In the corridors of philosophical discourse, Immanuel Kant stands as a colossus, his Critique of Pure Reason a guiding light illuminating the path to rational understanding. Yet, as with any monumental work, Kant’s magnum opus sparked not only adulation but also a maelstrom of critique and controversy. Now, in a collection meticulously assembled by Brigitte Sassen, the choir of voices from Kant’s era reverberate anew.
This masterful introduction lays bare the battleground of ideas that characterized the early reception of Kant’s philosophy. It deftly navigates through the intellectual currents of the time, shedding light on the major trends that shaped the empiricist reaction to Kant’s revolutionary ideas.
The first section of this compendium transports readers to the turbulent intellectual landscape of 18th-century Europe. Through the lenses of the Gottingen Review and the incisive pen of Christian Garve, we witness the initial salvos fired against Kant’s fortress of reason.
But the heart of the book lies in its subsequent sections, each devoted to a pivotal aspect of Kant’s philosophy. From the Transcendental Aesthetic to the thorny debates surrounding Idealism and the Categories, it meticulously curates a treasure trove of primary sources. We encounter the impassioned polemics of Dietrich Tiedemann, the probing inquiries of Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi, and the incisive critiques of J. C. G. Schaumann, among others.
As we traverse the intellectual battlegrounds of the past, we grapple with the fundamental questions that animated Kant’s contemporaries. What is the nature of space and causality? Are there pure concepts of reason beyond the realm of experience? Does Kant’s idealism pave the path to enlightenment or lead us into the abyss of skepticism?
In the appendices, the work provides invaluable biographical sketches, offering glimpses into the lives and minds of the thinkers who shaped the discourse surrounding Kant’s philosophy. These vignettes enrich our understanding of the intellectual ferment that characterized the age of enlightenment.
Kant’s Early Critics is more than a mere anthology; it is a collection of voices across time, a testament to the enduring vitality of philosophical inquiry. As we immerse ourselves in the rich variety of ideas woven by Kant and his interlocutors, we are reminded that the pursuit of truth is a perpetual dialectic, an ongoing conversation that transcends space and time.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment