Christopher Yates’s The Poetic Imagination in Heidegger and Schelling is an extraordinary excavation of the fertile intersections between two of German philosophy’s most profound thinkers, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling and Martin Heidegger, as they grapple with the enigmatic yet essential force of the imagination. This work does not merely juxtapose two towering figures of post-Kantian thought; rather, it carefully traces the subterranean currents of their respective philosophies, revealing the imagination’s role not as a secondary or peripheral theme, but as a transformative, foundational, and deeply poetic force that shapes their questioning of being, freedom, and creativity.
Yates challenges the prevailing tendency to subordinate the imagination to reason or dismiss it as an amorphous faculty of intuition. Through textual analysis and philosophical rigor, he brings to light the centrality of the imagination as a dynamic, mediating force in Schelling’s system and as a pivotal, if often implicit, element in Heidegger’s later ontological poetics. By combining these threads, Yates not only illuminates how Schelling’s exploration of the imagination’s generative power influenced Heidegger’s rethinking of metaphysics but also offers a vision of the imagination as an indispensable collaborator in the human engagement with truth.
Schelling, whose contributions often stand in the shadow of his contemporaries Hegel and Fichte, emerges in Yates’s study as a philosopher whose penetrating insights into the creative and ontological dimensions of imagination resist simple categorization. Yates traces Schelling’s evolving treatment of imagination, from its role in his early philosophy of identity to its key significance in his Freiheitsschrift. For Schelling, the imagination is not merely a subjective capacity but a force that unites oppositions—reason and intuition, freedom and necessity, nature and spirit—into a living, dynamic whole. Yates elucidates how Schelling’s vision of imagination as a form of ontological creativity anticipates later existential and phenomenological concerns, demonstrating that Schelling does not merely prefigure Heidegger but actively informs his later thinking.
Heidegger, whose philosophical trajectory after Being and Time turned increasingly toward poetry, art, and language, wrestles with the imagination in a manner deeply resonant with Schelling’s work. Yates situates Heidegger’s engagement with Schelling as a decisive moment in his turn away from metaphysics as representation toward a thinking of Ereignis, or the event of Being. By examining Heidegger’s 1936 lecture course on Schelling’s Freiheitsschrift and his readings of Hölderlin, Yates reveals how Heidegger appropriates and transforms Schelling’s insights into the imagination, shifting its significance from a metaphysical grounding principle to a poetic and projective opening of Being itself.
Yates’s study does not merely affirm the imagination’s theoretical importance; it enacts the very creativity it seeks to describe. His philosophical narrative is itself an imaginative endeavour, blending exegetical precision with interpretive daring. The imagination, as he presents it, is not confined to its historical treatment within German Idealism or phenomenology but becomes a force that calls forth new possibilities for philosophical inquiry. Yates demonstrates how the imagination undergirds Heidegger’s later exploration of poetic dwelling and the creative essence of truth, positing the poetic imagination as a means of attending to the openness and strife at the heart of Being.
By tracing the imagination’s trajectory from its Kantian origins to its Schellingian reconfiguration and Heideggerian culmination, Yates provides a compelling framework for understanding the imagination as both a philosophical and a poetic force. The book elucidates how the imagination enables the synthesis of the manifold in Kant, becomes a site of ontological freedom and creativity in Schelling, and ultimately transforms into a measure of poetic truth in Heidegger. This diachronic reading not only situates Yates’s work within a larger tradition but also positions it as a crucial intervention in contemporary debates about the relationship between metaphysics, aesthetics, and phenomenology.
The philosophical rigor of Yates’s analysis is matched by the aesthetic sensibility with which he engages his subjects. The poetic imagination, for both Schelling and Heidegger, resists reductive categorization; it is neither a mere faculty of the mind nor a static ontological principle but a living interplay between grounding and projection, necessity and freedom, the finite and the infinite. Yates captures this complexity, demonstrating how the imagination functions as a site of tension and resolution, a force that not only mediates but also transforms the very conditions of thought.
The Poetic Imagination in Heidegger and Schelling is more than a comparative study; it is a philosophical event that reawakens the imagination as a vital dimension of human existence. Yates’s work invites readers to reconsider the imaginative act not as a retreat into subjectivity but as an engagement with the poetic truth of the world. In this sense, his study is as much about the potential of the imagination as it is about its historical treatment, opening pathways for new philosophical reflections on art, language, and creativity.
In an era where the role of imagination in philosophy is often dismissed or overlooked, Yates offers a timely and transformative reconsideration. His work exemplifies how philosophical inquiry can itself become an act of poetic imagination, forging connections between thinkers, traditions, and ideas in a manner that is both rigorous and revelatory. For readers of German Idealism, phenomenology, and aesthetics, as well as for anyone interested in the intersections of philosophy and art, this book is an indispensable guide to the imaginative force that animates the search for truth.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment