Walter Kaufmann’s Discovering the Mind (Volume One: Goethe, Kant, and Hegel) is an ambitious exploration of intellectual history through the vivid psychologies, ideas, and personalities of three titanic figures who indelibly shaped the discourse of the human mind. With characteristic rigor, Kaufmann casts aside staid interpretations, offering instead a provocative and penetrating reevaluation of Goethe’s poetic vitality, Kant’s philosophical rigor, and Hegel’s dialectical ambition. His work is not merely a historical account but an exercise in psychohistory, where the character of the thinker is inseparable from their thought—an audacious rejection of the sterile detachment of traditional academic analysis.
In the first volume lies a fundamental dialectic between Goethe and Kant, two thinkers whose opposition in temperament, thought, and vision shaped the intellectual topography of German philosophy. Kaufmann introduces Goethe as a paragon of creative freedom and individual autonomy—an exemplar of what it means to live authentically, to embrace the full spectrum of one’s emotional and intellectual potential. Goethe’s Faust, Wilhelm Meister, and his scientific work exemplify the developmental nature of the mind, which Kaufmann heralds as an antidote to the rigid and static systems that would emerge under Kant’s influence. Goethe’s clarity of expression, his anti-idealist realism, and his insistence that truth is a process rather than a fixed destination, all point towards a dynamic, evolving conception of human nature. For Kaufmann, Goethe does not simply write about the mind; he enacts its development, embodying the integration of intellect and emotion, thought and action.
In stark contrast to Goethe’s expansive creativity stands Immanuel Kant’s formidable philosophical architecture—an edifice of critical inquiry aimed at securing the boundaries of human knowledge. Yet Kaufmann does not shy away from presenting Kant as a deeply flawed giant whose influence, however immense, was fundamentally catastrophic for the philosophy of mind. While acknowledging Kant’s brilliance and his essential clearing away of metaphysical debris, Kaufmann critiques Kant’s rigid insistence on certainty, necessity, and completeness as inimical to genuine discovery. Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason emerges not as a liberating exploration but as a self-defeating quest for absolute foundations, fostering a tradition of obscurity and dogmatism that would haunt subsequent German thought. Kant’s detached, impersonal method, Kaufmann argues, inhibits the very self-knowledge it seeks to uncover, stifling the vitality and openness necessary for intellectual progress.
Enter Hegel, the reconciler, who attempts to synthesize the seemingly irreconcilable visions of Goethe and Kant. Hegel’s grand dialectic, with its sweeping ambition to integrate logic, history, and mind, both fascinates and frustrates Kaufmann. Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit and his later works attempt to unify the rigor of Kantian critique with the organic developmentalism of Goethe, but Kaufmann shows that this synthesis is ultimately impossible. Hegel’s brilliance lies in his recognition of history’s role in shaping consciousness, yet his propensity for opaque jargon and his claims to systematic completeness betray a Kantian anxiety for closure. Hegel’s conceptual genius is tempered by Kaufmann’s insight that Hegel, despite his aspiration to encompass all reality within his logic, often obscures rather than illuminates the workings of the mind.
Kaufmann’s method is unapologetically personal and unorthodox, merging philosophical critique with biographical insight. He breaches the academic taboo against ad hominem inquiry, arguing that the psyche of the philosopher cannot be divorced from their philosophy. This is not reductionism but a recognition that understanding the thinker’s mind enriches our grasp of their ideas. Thus, Goethe’s autonomy is not merely a theoretical ideal but a lived reality; Kant’s pursuit of absolute rigor reflects his own psychological constraints; Hegel’s quest for totality mirrors his desire to transcend the fragmentation of modernity. For Kaufmann, the philosopher’s mind is a microcosm of their thought, and to understand one, we must investigate the other.
Moreover, Kaufmann challenges the fragmentation of intellectual disciplines that occurred in the wake of Kant and Hegel. He insists that the discovery of the mind cannot be confined to philosophy alone but must engage literature, psychology, and the lived experience of human beings. This interdisciplinary approach—a hallmark of German intellectual life before its division into specialized fields—is essential for any serious endeavor to understand the mind. Goethe’s literary genius, Kant’s philosophical acumen, and Hegel’s historical vision all contribute to a more comprehensive view of what it means to think, feel, and exist.
Kaufmann’s prose is as vivid and dynamic as his subjects. He writes with a Nietzschean tempo—swift, incisive, and unencumbered by the ponderousness of academic convention. His passion for clarity is matched by his disdain for obscurantism; he exposes the convoluted prose of Kant and Hegel not as a mark of profundity but as a failure of communication and, by extension, of thought. The philosopher’s style, Kaufmann argues, is inseparable from their philosophy—a clear mind writes clearly, while an obscure mind obfuscates.
Discovering the Mind is not merely an analysis of Goethe, Kant, and Hegel, but a bold plea for intellectual courage and self-knowledge. Kaufmann challenges us to reject the false comforts of systematic closure and to embrace the provisional, the developmental, and the uncertain. The mind, he suggests, is not a fixed object to be dissected but a dynamic process to be lived and discovered. By revisiting these three giants with fresh eyes, Kaufmann invites us to engage in the same fearless inquiry that animated their greatest insights. In doing so, he offers not just a history of ideas, but a philosophy of the mind as an ongoing, ever-evolving journey—a journey that demands both intellectual rigor and the courage to know oneself.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment