This is a work that presents one of the twentieth century’s most audacious and uncompromising explorations of the human mind caught in the tension between the solitary interiority of our unconscious lives and the currents of collective existence that sweep us beyond the orbit of our private reason. What this volume offers is no less than an intellectual panorama of a thinker who dared to look into the hidden chambers of cultural life, religion, politics, and memory, seeking to uncover the elemental forces that shape our loves and hatreds, our exaltations and anxieties, our devotion to leaders and gods, and our persistent human failure to live peaceably and without illusion. It is a selection of texts in which Sigmund Freud, pushing his psychoanalytic inquiries beyond the clinical setting and into the social cosmos, reveals how the desires and conflicts of individual psyches become entangled in the grand architectures of armies, churches, peoples, and traditions, and how ideas, symbols, and beliefs infiltrate our minds as hypnotic influences that lure us into mass formations and religious congregations, and that paradoxically both elevate ideals and can unleash savagery.
What emerges from these writings is an detailed map of the mind’s social topography. Freud does not rest at the surface of economic rivalry or political calculation. Instead, he insists that at the heart of the mass is a profound libidinal dynamic, a web of emotional ties that binds individuals together through love and identification just as much as it propels them into enmity and exclusion. In these texts, the notion of “mass psychology” is not a casual metaphor; it is a radical rethinking of what it means for individuals to join with others, willingly or not, to form something greater, and in some ways less, than themselves. The very structure of consciousness, according to Freud, is warped and rearranged under the pressure of collective life. Individual inhibitions and scruples fall away; the self, normally constructed through painstaking stages of renunciation, adaptation, and sublimation, merges into a larger configuration in which its uniqueness and self-awareness are surrendered to a shared affective pattern. The guiding fantasy, Freud argues, is that there exists somewhere a benevolent, powerful figure—an ideal leader, a God, a Moses—who loves all the individuals equally, granting them security and restoring a narcotic sense of unity. Under such an illusion, masses become both docile and ferocious, energetic and childlike, prone to sway under the spell of suggestion, imitation, and affective contagion.
Freud’s investigations in this volume do not seek to reassure. Instead, they expose the deepest contradictions that lie at the root of social bonds. From his reflections on religious belief, which he regards as simultaneously a comfort and a delusion, to his excavation of the origins of monotheistic faith in the violent primal events at the dawn of human culture, he shows us that no vision of civilization can be complete without acknowledging the subterranean currents of aggression, intolerance, and hatred that coexist with our loftiest ideals. In Mass Psychology and the Analysis of the ‘I’, he sets forth the idea that the primal father—the earliest authority figure—survives unconsciously in every religious and cultural tradition, haunting us with commands that we hear as divine or paternal voices and to which we respond by renouncing certain drives, forging identifications, and binding ourselves to one another in the recognition of a common obedience. This grim anthropology contends that civilizations are founded not only on reason and cooperation but also on crime, guilt, and a never-ending process of remembering and forgetting foundational traumas.
In related texts such as Compulsive Actions and Religious Exercises and A Religious Experience, Freud makes explicit the analogy between the neurotic’s private rituals and the believer’s sacred ceremonies, revealing how thin the line is between solitary obsession and communal devotion. Religion, in these analyses, appears as a universal neurotic symptom, a great collective effort to master unconscious anxieties through ritual repetitions and symbolic acts. Yet, at the same time, it functions as a powerful binding force, forging a sense of belonging that transcends the individual, thus curbing narcissism and redirecting hostility—though this redirection inevitably finds its target in outsiders and non-believers. In The Future of an Illusion, Freud concentrates his polemic against religious belief, insisting that it is a childish dependency that humankind will one day outgrow, though at the cost of confronting the world as it is: indifferent to our wishes, merciless in its natural catastrophes, and offering no divine protection against life’s dangers. Civilization, he argues, must learn to do without these illusions, to ground its ethical precepts and ideals in reason rather than faith. And yet, the difficulty here is palpable: reason may be weak, slow to persuade, and unable to offer the same immediate solace as illusions. Freud seems torn between the enlightenment aspiration to disenchanted maturity and the stubborn resilience of the human psyche, which clings to illusions as a shield against fear and frustration.
In the late text Moses the Man and Monotheistic Religion, Freud returns to the historical and ethnological dimension of mass psychology, proclaiming that the Jewish people’s religion, born from the trauma of primal murder and repressed history, stands as a unique case. Monotheism, relentless in its abstract purity and intolerant of idols, emerges as a key spiritual revolution that at once contracts and expands the human horizon. This strange, burdensome heritage not only produced a people capable of surviving millennia of persecution and exile but also inadvertently planted seeds of moral consciousness and ethical universalism. Freud thus depicts the Jewish tradition as a paradigmatic example of how a mass—here, a people bound by a common historical memory and religious law—can bear witness to the ambivalence and complexity of identification, tradition, and the unconscious forces that shape collective identity. Here he ponders how racism, anti-Semitism, and the irrational hatred unleashed by nationalism resonate with the repressed undercurrents of religious ideas and ancient crimes. The ambivalence of love and hate, devotion and resentment, identification and aggression emerges as a permanent human predicament.
Throughout these writings, the tension between the conscious and unconscious layers of our mental life is never resolved. Freud’s goal is not to offer a recipe for constructing a better or more just society, nor to assure readers that truth and reason will inevitably triumph. Instead, he challenges us to understand the precarious equilibrium that civilizations maintain: how armies, despite their cruelty and hierarchical rigidity, function as powerful artificial masses in which comradeship, mutual sacrifice, and devotion to the leader promise glory or at least survival; how churches, in their promise of universal brotherly love under a divine father, ironically perpetuate intolerance and sometimes unleash violence against those who do not share their creed; how even the most seemingly rational and enlightened societies remain vulnerable to collective regression into states of panic, paranoia, and destructive fury. What Freud uncovers in the darkness of the unconscious is that masses are driven not simply by ideas or practical interests but by a psychic energy—libido—that recasts social relations in the shape of amorous ties, identifications, and the longing for a central, beloved figure.
This volume, therefore, is not an easy or comforting read. It thrusts us into the heart of one of the most disquieting legacies of psychoanalysis: the recognition that our cultural achievements and institutions, our moral codes and religious doctrines, are at once noble edifices and precarious façades behind which primitive desires, childish illusions, and irrational passions lie in wait. Yet it is also a testament to Freud’s intellectual courage and moral seriousness that he not only diagnosed our human frailties but also forced us to confront our illusions with honesty. With great detail, scrupulous rationality, and philosophical audacity, he leads us through mass phenomena, analyzing the unconscious attachment mechanisms at work in group identifications, dissecting the subtle transitions from object-love to identification, from narcissism to communal solidarity, from primal guilt to religious piety, and from faith to fanaticism.
In encountering this text, one stands before a master who simultaneously shatters our comforting notions of rational self-mastery and discloses the hidden emotional logic underlying our collective life. Freud’s exploration stands at the confluence of anthropology, sociology, psychology, and philosophy, projecting his psychoanalytic insights far beyond the couch and into the destiny of civilizations. Here is a collection that invites us to understand how the same drives that shape the earliest attachments of childhood also lend themselves to the thunderous clamour of the crowd, the hypnotic fascination of the charismatic leader, and the fervent reverence of religious faith. He reminds us that the cheerful surface of civilized existence is never secure against eruptions of cruel instinctual life, and that the true measure of enlightenment is how courageously we endure this knowledge and how wisely we learn to reckon with it.
In these writings, then, we have Freud at his most systematically pessimistic and at his most defiant, turning the lens of psychoanalysis onto history, politics, and society, and offering us no comfortable escape. It is an achievement of personal bravery and scientific boldness, carrying the stamp of a man who, at the twilight of his life, confronted his own heritage, religion, and culture, tested their foundations, and found them resting on ambiguous and troubling psychic processes. As we read these pages, we witness Freud grappling with anti-Semitism and racism, trying to decipher the malignant secret that leads peoples to hate and persecute one another, as well as the mysterious endurance of the Jewish people’s belief in an invisible God and their loyalty to a religious tradition that had cost them dearly. Freud, driven from Vienna into exile, did not relent in his determination to understand the unconscious currents that animate such terrible patterns of mass hatred. Rather than retreating into a comforting narrative, he insisted on examining these dark truths with unwavering candor.
The value of this volume lies not only in its historical importance but also in its continuing relevance. In an age perennially troubled by ideological fanaticism, political propaganda, religious extremism, ethnic strife, and mass manipulation, Freud’s analysis of the mass mind and its libidinal underpinnings remains a critical tool. It calls on us to unmask the illusions we collectively cherish, to investigate the subtle threads of emotional dependence tying us to leaders and fellow believers, and to grasp that the rational individual so proudly championed by modern thought is never far from losing itself in a communal frenzy. Freud’s textual legacy, assembled here with expert translation and insightful editorial choices, offers a rare and indispensable vantage point from which to contemplate the daunting complexity of human social life.
This collection—Mass Psychology & Other Writings—brings together Freud’s most challenging and illuminating treatments of the mass phenomenon, religious illusions, cultural traditions, and the unconscious prejudices and ancestral memories lurking beneath the surface of civilized conduct. It is not a manifesto or a program for reform but an invitation to deeper understanding. The reader who braves its complexity and resists the temptation to dismiss its unsettling claims will find in it a monument to the permanent tension between the rational and the irrational, the individual and the collective, love and hate, belief and delusion. It stands as a great work of psychoanalytic inquiry and philosophical depth, illuminating the shadows that fall when individuals gather together, abandon their isolated minds, and submit to the uncanny force of the mass. It is, in the end, a masterful exposition of the truths—and the illusions—by which humankind organizes itself into shared communities, carries forward its darkest traditions, and dreams, despite all evidence to the contrary, of a more enlightened future.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment