Nietzsche’s Journey to Sorrento: Genesis of the Philosophy of the Free Spirit by Paolo D’Iorio, as translated by Sylvia Gorelick, offers an in-depth and revealing portrait of Friedrich Nietzsche during a pivotal moment in his life and philosophy. In this compelling narrative, D’Iorio goes into the deep transformation Nietzsche experienced while spending time in southern Italy, particularly in the coastal town of Sorrento, in 1876. The journey, prompted by an invitation from his close friend Malwida von Meysenbug, marked a rupture not just in Nietzsche’s personal life but also in the trajectory of his intellectual development. D’Iorio skillfully combines historical context, biographical detail, and philosophical insight to trace the genesis of Nietzsche’s philosophy of the free spirit—an idea that would later come to define much of his mature works, including Human, All Too Human.
At the age of thirty-two, Nietzsche was undergoing a crisis of both body and spirit. Chronic physical ailments, particularly debilitating migraines, compounded his dissatisfaction with the direction his life had taken, particularly in his role as a professor at the University of Basel. This period of suffering coincided with an intellectual disillusionment with his previous allegiances, particularly his fervent support of Richard Wagner and his metaphysical aesthetics. The failure of Wagner’s festival at Bayreuth in 1876 furthered Nietzsche’s disenchantment, and it was amidst this existential turmoil that he made the decision to embrace the restorative powers of the Italian South. There, beneath the warm sun of Sorrento, Nietzsche began to peel away the layers of his previous philosophical commitments, ultimately forging a new path that would lead to the break with Wagner and the birth of the “philosophy of the free spirit.”
D’Iorio brings this transformation to life through Nietzsche’s personal writings, including excerpts from his notebooks, the Sorrentiner Papiere, where we can trace the emergence of his aphoristic style and the seeds of ideas that would later appear in Human, All Too Human. The philosopher’s decision to leave behind the metaphysical and aesthetic views of his earlier works is presented not as an abrupt rupture, but as a gradual and painful realization that his previous outlook—rooted in the aesthetics of Wagnerian music and the metaphysics of Schopenhauer—was untenable. Nietzsche’s intellectual awakening, alongside his physical rest in the idyllic surroundings of Sorrento, is depicted as a rebirth. The very environment of Sorrento, with its lush gardens, views of the Mediterranean Sea, and proximity to the volcanic presence of Mount Vesuvius, symbolized a new beginning, providing Nietzsche with both the external and internal space to question, critique, and ultimately redefine his philosophical ambitions.
D’Iorio also highlights the crucial role of Nietzsche’s relationships during this time, particularly with his friend Paul Rée, and his evolving interactions with Malwida von Meysenbug. These friendships are crucial to understanding the intellectual ferment that took place in Sorrento, as Nietzsche, Rée, and others spent long hours in conversation, reading, and writing. The intellectual climate of the villa they shared in Sorrento—a place of shared solitude and reflection—became a crucible for Nietzsche’s emerging ideas. Nietzsche’s sharp turn toward the “free spirit” can be seen in his growing discontent with the idea of a metaphysical or artistic redemption of humanity, a shift that would forever change the course of Western philosophy. The “free spirit” Nietzsche came to envision was one who transcended the limitations of inherited traditions, cultural norms, and moral constraints to embrace a life led by a personal pursuit of truth and intellectual freedom.
One of the most striking features of D’Iorio’s account is how it joins Nietzsche’s personal journey with the broader philosophical currents of the time. The book is not simply a biography; it is a meditation on the evolution of Nietzsche’s thought. Through the lens of Nietzsche’s physical and intellectual transformation in the South, D’Iorio explores the philosophical significance of the free spirit—a concept that Nietzsche would later develop further in Thus Spoke Zarathustra and Beyond Good and Evil. The free spirit, in Nietzsche’s view, was not a figure of defiance for its own sake, but rather an individual who had liberated themselves from the constraints of conventional morality and the weight of tradition, living instead with an unflinching commitment to the pursuit of knowledge and the affirmation of life.
Throughout the book, D’Iorio also provides insights into Nietzsche’s relationship with his former mentor, Wagner. Their final interaction in Sorrento, marked by an intellectual and emotional distance, is depicted with a sense of quiet finality. The encounter between the two figures—once so aligned in their dreams of a cultural renaissance through art—was tainted by Wagner’s increasing turn toward Christian mysticism and a more conservative, nationalistic view of German culture. Nietzsche’s growing disillusionment with Wagner’s religious turn is presented as the final fracture in their once-intimate relationship, an emotional and intellectual rupture that would have lasting consequences for Nietzsche’s philosophy.
As D’Iorio guides us through the days spent in Sorrento, he vividly reconstructs the sensory and emotional world of Nietzsche during this transformative period. The beauty of the Sorrentine landscape, the quietude of the villa, and the camaraderie of his intellectual circle all played significant roles in Nietzsche’s philosophical evolution. D’Iorio’s writing is rich with detail, bringing the philosophical ideas to life not only through the content of Nietzsche’s notes but also through the atmospheric quality of the Sorrentine experience itself.
The book’s appeal lies in its ability to capture a moment of intellectual and personal transformation while also offering a broader reflection on the nature of philosophical creativity and the inner life of the thinker. Nietzsche’s Journey to Sorrento is not merely a travelogue of a philosopher in transition, but a study of the very processes by which ideas evolve, often against the backdrop of personal struggle and existential questioning. By placing Nietzsche’s work within the historical and geographical context of southern Italy, D’Iorio offers an innovative lens through which to understand the origins of the philosophy of the free spirit—an ethos that continues to resonate in contemporary discussions on freedom, individuality, and the role of philosophy in personal and cultural renewal.
Nietzsche’s Journey to Sorrento: Genesis of the Philosophy of the Free Spirit is a deeply erudite and richly textured narrative that brings to light the intellectual genesis of Nietzsche’s most significant philosophical ideas. It portrays a philosopher at a crossroads, engaging with his past, his suffering, and his aspirations for the future. Through D’Iorio’s expert scholarship, we are afforded a rare glimpse into the philosophical maturation of one of the most influential figures in modern thought, making this book an essential read for those interested in the intersection of philosophy, biography, and intellectual history.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment