Hegel’s Shorter Logic: An Introduction and Commentary by John Grier Hibben and Eric v.d. Luft is a monumental contribution to Hegelian scholarship, offering an in-depth exploration of Hegel’s Encyclopedia Logic. Since its original publication in 1902, Hibben’s work has been celebrated for its clarity and insightful interpretation of Hegel’s philosophical system. This revised edition, significantly expanded and modernized by Eric v.d. Luft, not only updates the language and references but also incorporates contemporary Hegel scholarship, situating the work within a broader historical and philosophical context.
At the heart of this commentary is the recognition that Hegel’s Logic is not merely a study of formal reasoning but an all-encompassing system of philosophy that seeks to comprehend the universe through the self-unfolding of the Idea. Logic, in Hegel’s sense, is the systematic knowledge of the pure Idea—the very essence of thought and being. Hibben and Luft analyse this complex framework, guiding readers through the dialectical movements that characterize Hegel’s method. They emphasize that the Logic serves as both the foundation and culmination of Hegel’s entire philosophical enterprise, revealing the dynamic process by which thought develops from immediacy to absolute knowledge.
One of the central themes explored is the dialectical triad of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis—a process that underpins the progression of thought in Hegel’s system. The authors elucidate how each concept or category in the Logic inherently contains contradictions that propel it toward its opposite, necessitating a higher synthesis that resolves the tension. This movement is not linear but circular, reflecting Hegel’s notion that philosophy, and indeed reality itself, is a “circle of circles.” Each part of the system is both a whole in itself and a component of a larger totality, illustrating the interdependence of concepts and the unfolding of the Absolute.
Hibben and Luft go into the relation between thought and being, a cornerstone of Hegelian philosophy. They examine Hegel’s assertion that the laws of thought are identical to the laws of reality, a perspective that dissolves the traditional dualism between subject and object. This unity is manifested in the concept (Begriff), which Hegel sees as the living essence of both thought and things. The authors discuss how the concept operates as the driving force of the dialectical process, embodying the active, dynamic nature of reason as it actualizes itself in the world.
A significant contribution of Luft’s revision is the modernizing of Hegel’s technical vocabulary, making the dense and often perplexing terminology more accessible to contemporary readers. For instance, the distinction between “abstract” and “concrete” is thoroughly explored. In Hegel’s usage, “abstract” refers to one-sided, incomplete perspectives that isolate concepts from their relations, while “concrete” denotes a comprehensive understanding that integrates all aspects and connections. Hibben and Luft illustrate how the movement from the abstract to the concrete is essential for grasping the true nature of reality, as it reflects the process by which thought reconciles contradictions and achieves wholeness.
The commentary also addresses the historical context of Hegel’s Logic, situating it within the broader trajectory of Western philosophy. The authors discuss Hegel’s engagement with his predecessors, such as Aristotle, Descartes, Spinoza, and Kant, highlighting how Hegel both builds upon and critiques their ideas. They emphasize Hegel’s departure from Cartesian dualism and foundationalism, underscoring his anti-foundationalist stance that philosophy cannot presuppose any axioms or starting points. Instead, Hegel begins with pure, indeterminate being—which is equivalent to nothing—and through the dialectical process arrives at the Absolute Idea, a fully mediated and concrete universal.
In exploring the method of the Logic, Hibben and Luft shed light on Hegel’s critique of traditional logic and metaphysics. They explain that for Hegel, the movement of thought is not governed by external forms or imposed structures but arises organically from the inner contradictions and dynamics of concepts themselves. This self-generating process reflects the inherent rationality of reality, as reason unfolds and actualizes itself through the dialectical progression. The authors clarify how Hegel’s Logic serves as both an epistemological and ontological inquiry, merging the study of knowledge with the study of being.
The treatment of the dialectical method is particularly noteworthy. Hibben and Luft carefully analyse each stage of the triadic movement, illustrating how the initial position (thesis) inevitably gives rise to its opposition (antithesis) due to inherent limitations and contradictions. The resolution (synthesis) emerges not as a mere compromise but as a higher unity that transcends and includes the preceding moments. This process is seen as the engine of development in thought, nature, and spirit, driving the evolution toward greater complexity and integration.
Hibben and Luft also address the challenges of engaging with Hegel’s dense and often enigmatic prose. They acknowledge the difficulty many readers face when approaching the Logic and provide strategies for overcoming these obstacles. By offering clear explanations, concrete examples, and careful interpretations, they make Hegel’s ideas more approachable without diluting their complexity. Luft’s additions, including updated translations, expanded glossaries, and cross-references to Hegel’s other works, enhance the usability of the commentary as both an introductory text and a scholarly resource.
The exploration of the unity of thought and being extends to a discussion of absolute idealism, the philosophical stance that reality is the manifestation of an absolute, all-encompassing mind or spirit (Geist). The authors explain how Hegel conceives of the Absolute not as a static entity but as a dynamic process that realizes itself through the unfolding of history, nature, and individual consciousness. This perspective challenges traditional notions of God and metaphysics, offering a vision of reality as a self-developing whole in which the finite and the infinite are intrinsically connected.
In examining the implications of Hegel’s Logic for other areas of philosophy, Hibben and Luft touch upon its influence on ethics, politics, and history. They discuss how the dialectical method applies to social and historical phenomena, illustrating the progression of freedom, reason, and self-consciousness in human affairs. The authors highlight Hegel’s impact on subsequent philosophical movements, including Marxism and existentialism, and reflect on the enduring relevance of his ideas in contemporary debates.
Throughout the commentary, Hibben and Luft maintain a delicate balance between fidelity to Hegel’s original text and the provision of critical analysis. They do not shy away from addressing contentious interpretations or potential inconsistencies within Hegel’s system. For instance, they explore debates surrounding foundationalism versus anti-foundationalism in Hegel’s philosophy, considering arguments that the Logic both begins without presuppositions and yet seems to presuppose pure being as its starting point. By engaging with such complexities, the authors encourage readers to think critically and develop their own understanding of Hegel’s thought.
The book’s comprehensive approach extends to methodological considerations, as Hibben and Luft reflect on the nature of philosophy itself. They echo Hegel’s sentiment that philosophy must go beyond mere opinion or unexamined belief, engaging in rigorous, systematic inquiry that uncovers the rational structures underlying reality. Philosophy is portrayed as a transformative endeavor that requires the courage to confront contradictions and the perseverance to seek higher truth.
Hegel’s Shorter Logic: An Introduction and Commentary is an indispensable work that offers a detailed examination of one of philosophy’s most challenging texts. The collaboration between Hibben and Luft results in a commentary that is both deeply rooted in historical scholarship and responsive to contemporary interpretive needs. By demystifying Hegel’s Logic and illuminating its intricate pathways, the authors open the door for readers to engage meaningfully with the profound questions at the heart of Hegel’s philosophy. The book shows the enduring significance of Hegel’s thought and serves as a valuable guide for anyone seeking to navigate the complexities of the dialectical method and the unfolding of the Absolute.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment