David S. Stern’s Essays on Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit is a scholarly investigation into one of the least explored but one of the most intricate aspects of Hegelian thought: the Philosophy of Subjective Spirit. This volume, the first English-language collection of its kind, does not merely seek to resurrect a neglected area of Hegel’s Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences; it establishes a fertile new ground for understanding the interplay between the natural and the spiritual, the corporeal and the ideal, the immanent and the transcendent. Stern brings together a diverse group of scholars to illuminate Hegel’s treatment of subjective spirit, presenting an anthology that is both historically grounded and intensely relevant to contemporary debates in philosophy of mind, psychology, and the broader discourse on human nature.
Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit grapples with the fundamental transition from nature to spirit, a metamorphosis that underscores the entire trajectory of the Encyclopedia. This anthology addresses topics ranging from the soul-body relation and the dialectical emergence of consciousness to the embodiment of habit and the ideality of rational freedom. The essays explore how subjective spirit evolves from its immediate, natural immersion—characterized as the “sleep” of spirit—to its eventual self-realization as free, rational activity. In this way, the work of Stern and his contributors elucidates the crucial mediatory function of subjective spirit, linking the empirical and contingent realm of natural existence with the more universal structures of objective and absolute spirit.
One of the book’s many achievements lies in its engagement with both Hegel’s original texts and the historical contexts that shaped them. Drawing on newly accessible transcripts and editorial work associated with Hegel’s lecture series, the contributors situate the Philosophy of Subjective Spirit within the broader spectrum of Hegel’s systematic philosophy. The rediscovery of lecture notes, particularly the Erdmann Nachschrift, opens a new lens for understanding how Hegel refined his concepts of soul, feeling, and habit through rigorous interaction with contemporaneous developments in science, metaphysics, and psychology.
Central to this discussion is the anthropological foundation of spirit. Hegel’s conception of the soul as the “universal immateriality of nature” and the foundational substrate of spiritual development is a key theme throughout the essays. The contributors demonstrate that for Hegel, the soul is not a thing or a fixed substance but a dynamic process—nature’s first, tentative step toward freedom. This speculative reframing of the soul-body relationship transcends the traditional dualism of mind and matter, offering a hylomorphic account of spirit that integrates the biological and the psychological. By presenting the soul as both immanent in nature and as the principle of its transcendence, the essays highlight the dialectical tension that drives the development of subjective spirit.
The volume also emphasizes Hegel’s engagement with contemporary scientific and philosophical concerns, a facet of his work often overlooked in English-language scholarship. Hegel’s inclusion of phenomena such as dreams, madness, and the paranormal within the scope of subjective spirit reveals his commitment to exploring the full spectrum of human experience, from its most grounded biological manifestations to its most abstract rational expressions. The essays argue that Hegel’s reflections on these topics anticipate and enrich modern debates in philosophy of mind, particularly those concerning embodiment, intentionality, and the naturalization of cognition.
A recurring motif in the anthology is the role of habit (Gewohnheit) as the linchpin of Hegel’s anthropology and psychology. Habit emerges as the mechanism through which spirit reconciles its natural immediacy with its capacity for reflective freedom. This concept, brilliantly dissected in the essays, underscores the embodied nature of all spiritual activity. For Hegel, even the highest acts of thought and reason presuppose a substrate of habituated bodily and social practices. This insight resonates deeply with contemporary theories of embodied cognition and second nature, suggesting that Hegel’s philosophy offers a robust framework for bridging the gap between naturalistic and idealist accounts of the human mind.
Stern’s anthology does not shy away from the methodological challenges posed by Hegel’s dense and speculative system. The contributors adopt a range of interpretive strategies, from historical contextualization to systematic reconstruction, to illuminate the Philosophy of Subjective Spirit as a living and dynamic component of Hegel’s thought. Essays by scholars such as Robert R. Williams and Angelica Nuzzo go into the architecture of Hegel’s system, revealing how the development of subjective spirit integrates and transforms earlier moments in the Encyclopedia, particularly the transition from nature to spirit and the relation between anthropology and psychology.
Equally compelling is the volume’s exploration of Hegel’s relevance to contemporary philosophy. By engaging with modern thinkers and issues—such as the embodied mind, the neuroscience of habit, and the nature of freedom—the essays demonstrate that Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit is not a mere relic of 19th-century speculation but a fertile source of insights for addressing perennial and emerging philosophical questions. The contributors’ ability to traverse the historical and the contemporary, the systematic and the empirical, marks the collection as a landmark achievement in Hegelian scholarship.
Essays on Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit is an invitation to reimagine the possibilities of Hegelian philosophy. By bringing to light the interplay of nature and spirit, freedom and necessity, individuality and universality, Stern and his contributors set the stage for a new phase of engagement with Hegel’s work. This volume is an essential resource for Hegel scholars, philosophers of mind, and anyone seeking to understand the complex dynamics of human existence as envisioned by one of philosophy’s greatest systematic thinkers. It reaffirms Hegel’s relevance not only as a philosopher of his time but as a thinker whose insights continue to challenge and inspire in our own.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment