Adam Kotsko’s Žižek and Theology offers an extensive and nuanced analysis of Slavoj Žižek’s engagement with Christian theology, providing an indispensable guide for readers seeking to navigate the complex intersections between Žižek’s dialectical materialism and theological thought. In this detailed examination, Kotsko goes into Žižek’s broader intellectual trajectory and its convergence with theological themes, contextualizing Žižek’s theological interests within his larger philosophical project.
Žižek, the Slovenian philosopher and psychoanalyst often described as an “academic rock star,” has captivated both the public and academic spheres with his provocative ideas. His work, which spans four decades, has in the last years increasingly intersected with Christian theology. Žižek’s engagement with Christian thought is not just a peripheral aspect of his work but a crucial component of his broader intellectual agenda. His references to and reinterpretations of key Christian thinkers—ranging from Paul and Pascal to Kierkegaard, Chesterton, and C.S. Lewis—are not superficial or incidental but are woven into the fabric of his philosophical inquiries.
Kotsko’s book serves as both an introduction and a detailed exposition of Žižek’s theological thought, tracing its development from his early engagements with Hegel, Lacan, and Marx to his more recent theological musings. By placing Žižek’s theological work in the context of his broader intellectual framework, Kotsko elucidates the ways in which Žižek’s Marxist and Lacanian perspectives intersect with and challenge traditional Christian doctrines.
Central to Žižek’s theological exploration is his assertion that a profound understanding of Christianity can enhance and even transform dialectical materialism. Žižek provocatively claims that “to become a true dialectical materialist, one should go through the Christian experience.” This assertion is not just a call for religious conversion but also a proposition that Christian theological insights can provide a critical lens through which to engage with materialist theory. Žižek’s assertion underscores a radical reinterpretation of Christianity, where the theological elements are employed as a means to critique and subvert contemporary ideological structures.
Kotsko’s analysis begins by situating Žižek’s theological inquiries within his broader philosophical project. Žižek’s early works, which focused on ideology critique through the lens of Lacanian psychoanalysis and Hegelian dialectics, laid the groundwork for his later theological engagements. In The Sublime Object of Ideology and subsequent texts, Žižek critiques the ideological structures that underpin modern capitalist societies, utilizing Lacan’s theory of the Real, the Big Other, and jouissance to dissect how ideologies perpetuate themselves.
As Žižek’s work evolved, his focus shifted toward a more explicit engagement with theological themes. Kotsko carefully traces this shift, demonstrating how Žižek’s Marxist critique of ideology and his Lacanian approach to subjectivity and ethics intersect with his theological reflections. Žižek’s interest in Christianity is not an abandonment of his materialist commitments but a strategic move to expose and critique the ideological underpinnings of contemporary belief systems.
A significant aspect of Žižek’s theological discourse is his reinterpretation of Christian figures and concepts. For instance, Žižek reconfigures the figure of Christ in a manner that challenges conventional Christian understandings. He posits that Jesus, rather than being a mere redeemer or a new Moses, should be seen as a figure akin to Job—one who confronts the meaninglessness of suffering without the traditional theodicies offered by God. This reinterpretation reflects Žižek’s broader critique of the “big Other,” which represents the ultimate authority or symbolic order in both religious and secular contexts.
Žižek’s engagement with theology also manifests in his critique of liberal democracy and nationalism. By employing Christian theological concepts, Žižek critiques the ideological function of modern political systems, arguing that they are sustained by a kind of perverse enjoyment or jouissance that disguises their underlying contradictions. His approach suggests that Christianity, when stripped of its institutional trappings, can offer a radical critique of the ideological status quo.
Kotsko’s book addresses these themes in a comprehensive manner, providing a critical overview of Žižek’s theological contributions. He discusses how Žižek’s theology is deeply connected with his critique of ideology and his dialectical materialism. The book explores Žižek’s radical rethinking of Christian concepts, such as the Holy Spirit and the notion of divine love, through the lens of his materialist and psychoanalytic frameworks. Kotsko emphasizes that Žižek’s theological reflections are not attempts to recover traditional religious beliefs but rather to use theology as a critical tool against entrenched ideological systems.
In examining theological responses to Žižek’s work, Kotsko provides an overview of various theological reactions, including those from Radical Orthodoxy and other theological traditions. These responses highlight the contentious nature of Žižek’s theological interventions and the ways in which they challenge conventional religious thinking. Kotsko also discusses Žižek’s method of correlation, which attempts to bridge the gap between theology and materialist critique, and examines how Žižek’s ideas resonate with or diverge from traditional theological positions.
Overall, Kotsko’s Žižek and Theology is a crucial resource for those seeking to understand the complex relationship between Žižek’s philosophical project and his theological engagements. It provides a thorough and nuanced analysis of Žižek’s use of Christian theology as a tool for ideological critique and philosophical reflection. For theologians and philosophers alike, Kotsko’s book offers valuable insights into the intersection of materialism and theology, highlighting the ways in which Žižek’s work challenges and enriches contemporary theological discourse.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment