Politics and Teleology in Kant, edited by Paul Formosa, Avery Goldman, and Tatiana Patrone, is an examination of the relationship between teleology and politics in Immanuel Kant’s philosophy. This scholarly collection comprises fourteen essays from leading experts, each exploring the ways in which Kant’s political philosophy is influenced by his teleological understanding of nature and history.
The introduction by the editors serves as a comprehensive overview, presenting the central theme of reconciling Kant’s normative political theory with his a priori moral philosophy and his teleological philosophy of nature and human history. The editors emphasize that, for Kant, political philosophy cannot be extricated from its natural and historical context, and likewise, understanding nature and history necessitates a normative political perspective. According to Kant, the historical trajectory of humanity and its natural predispositions ultimately lead toward the realization of a just society, where human reason and morality achieve their fullest expression.
The volume describes how Kant envisions the role of nature and history in shaping political structures and the moral progress of humanity. Grounded in Kant’s critical works such as the Critique of Judgment, Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim, and Toward Perpetual Peace, the essays explore the interplay between natural teleology, cosmopolitanism, and public reason. The scholars collectively argue that Kant’s teleological approach, though often misunderstood or deemed obsolete in the wake of Darwinian evolution, remains crucial for comprehending his vision of politics and history. They assert that Kant’s teleology provides a framework for understanding the purposiveness inherent in nature and history, which aligns with the moral development and political progress of humanity.
The essays analyse Kant’s cosmopolitanism and his perspectives on international relations, revealing his belief in a gradual progression towards global peace and justice through lawful and moral means. Kant advocated for a federation of free states governed by principles of right, emphasizing the moral duties of states beyond mere prudential concerns. His ideas on perpetual peace are linked to his broader teleological view of history, where human conflicts and the use of reason propel humanity towards a cosmopolitan condition. This vision of perpetual peace underscores Kant’s commitment to a global order rooted in justice and moral principles, rather than mere political expediency.
Methodological challenges in interpreting Kant’s political theory through a teleological lens are addressed head-on. The contemporary skepticism towards teleological explanations, often seen as outdated, is countered by elucidating Kant’s nuanced use of teleology as a regulative principle. Rather than asserting metaphysical truths, Kant’s teleology serves as a heuristic tool to understand the purposiveness in nature and history, which in turn supports human moral development and political progress. This approach highlights the philosophical depth of Kant’s teleological reasoning and its relevance in understanding his political philosophy.
Public reason and civic education are central themes in Kant’s political philosophy, and the essays in this volume emphasize their importance. Public reason is crucial for achieving political legitimacy and moral progress, necessitating a public sphere where citizens engage in rational discourse. Kant’s principles of publicity are presented as practical tools for evaluating the morality and justice of political actions, ensuring that political maxims are transparent and subject to public scrutiny. This emphasis on public reason reflects Kant’s commitment to an enlightened citizenry capable of self-governance through rational deliberation.
The exploration of justice and civic fellowship in Kant’s political theory reveals an implicit account of civic attitudes and virtues necessary for a functioning political community. The essays argue for a reading of Kant that includes a vision of citizens as partners in legislation, fostering a sense of shared moral purpose. This civic fellowship is essential for the stability and progress of a just society, as it cultivates mutual respect and cooperation among citizens.
Politics and Teleology in Kant offers a thorough and insightful elaboration of the ways in which Kant’s teleological views informed and shaped his political philosophy. It stands as an indispensable resource for Kant scholars and students in moral and political philosophy, the philosophy of history, political theory, and related fields. By enhancing our understanding of Kant’s political thought, this volume also contributes to broader discussions on the relevance of teleological reasoning in contemporary political theory. The essays collectively underscore the enduring significance of Kant’s philosophical framework, inviting readers to reconsider the role of teleology in the development of political ideas and the pursuit of a just society.
Simon Gros 
Leave a comment